10 Perfect Joe Montana Football Card Investments

This post contains affiliate links. Read the full disclosure here

Sports fans worldwide love to collect trading cards of their favorite athletes. Having tokens attributed to their ideals is a fun pass time many fans invest in. The legendary NFL quarterback Joe Montana is no exception.

Montana is widely known as one of the greatest football quarterbacks in history. After his fourteen-year run with the San Francisco 49ers and the Kansas City Chiefs, Montana established himself as one of the all-time greats with his whip-like arm, uncanny ability to read the opposing team’s defense, and four career Super Bowl wins.

How much are Joe Montana football cards worth?

The 1981 Joe Montana football rookie card at a PSA 10 grade is currently worth $80,000 (please note this is an average), $1,800 at a PSA 9 grade, $350 at a PSA 8, $190 (PSA 7), and $150 at a PSA 6 grade.

What is the best Joe Montana rookie card?

The best Joe Montana rookie card is his 1981 Topps football rookie card. This card has had an average ROI near 30% over the last four years and is also the most valuable Joe Montana rookie card.

Trending:
The 12 Greatest Babe Ruth Baseball Cards To Invest In
Top Michael Jordan Basketball Cards Under $500
10 Greatest Pete Rose Baseball Cards
Top 5 Luka Doncic Rookie Card Investments

Despite the champ’s retirement in the 1990s, Joe Montana Football Card investments remain lucrative and highly coveted. Joe Montana football cards are rare and considered football classics, particularly due to the player’s fame in the 1980s. You can purchase these cards for as little as $250.00 all the way up to five figures. 

Let’s check out the top 5 perfect Joe Montana Football card investments.

 

1981 Joe Montana Topps RC #216

1981 Joe Montana Topps RC #216

  • Price: ($69,000 PSA 10)
  • Year: 1981
  • Card number: #216
  • Team: San Francisco 49ers

The 1981 Topps Joe Montana Card features a young Montana in his second season playing professional football. The #216 has an air-brushed front showing Montana ready to throw a football in his iconic number ’16’ Jersey in the gold and white 49ers uniform. The card has the classic green Tops border with Montana’s name and position in the bottom left corner. The background looks like a blurred stadium suggesting that Montana is participating in a serious football game.

Arguably the first major Joe Montana card, the #216 proved to be a phenomenal hit since the quarterback would go on to become one of the many NFL Hall of Famers. The card would mark the beginning of the 24-year-old Montana’s first season as the starting quarterback for the 49ers. Montana shocked the world with his strong performance and managed to finish the 1981 Regular season with a 13-3 record. He also saved the 49ers by making two 4th-quarter comebacks in Regular season games that were seemingly lost. 

Montana would go on to dominate the league with another rare feat. He led his team to Super Bowl XVI and became one of the few quarterbacks in NFL history to win a Super Bowl in their first year as the starter. Montana would also win the Super Bowl Most Valuable Player Award and establish the San Francisco 49ers dynasty throughout the 1980s.

Montana would orchestrate another iconic moment in 1982 by throwing a game-winning touchdown pass to receiver Dwight Clark to win the NFC Championship Game over the Dallas Cowboys. Clark’s fantastic chemistry with Montana led to a beautiful touchdown pass known as ‘the Catch.’ 

Joe Montana led the 49ers to four Super Bowl appearances (XVI, XIX, XXIII, XXIV) and was named MVP thrice. 

Therefore, #216 is one of the best Joe Montana Football card investments and has only two active PSA 10 versions in circulation. It is widely considered the most expensive Joe Montana football card as it shows the young quarterback before he would become one of the all-time greats. However, less authentic ungraded copies are available for as little as $86.

 

1990 Joe Montana Pro Set Super Bowl MVP Error #273

1990 Joe Montana Pro Set Super Bowl XXV

Price: ($260.55 PSA 9)

Year: 1990

Set number: 1990 Pro Set

Team: San Francisco 49ers

This 1990-91 Pro Set Joe Montana Super BowlXXV 49ers Football card shows a picture of Joe Montana, the legendary running back for the San Francisco 49ers. Montana broke the NFL record for most rushing yards in a single game in 1991 and is one of the most popular players to ever grace a football card. His career spanned ten years and included multiple Pro Bowl appearances and 1,000+ yard seasons.

While the official release of the card was not until 1989, it made its way onto some collectors’ lists. The most popular is the one with Emmitt Smith, who was the first round draft pick in 1990. Although the season was not a banner year, the Cowboys did improve upon their previous seasons and Smith was an explosive runner out of the backfield. His rookie card was immediately popular and still holds its top spot in the 1990 Pro Set. He went on to have a Hall of Fame career and holds the franchise rushing record.

The 1990-91 Pro Set football card issue had a few variants and errors. The first version of the card featured Eric Dickerson, but due to a contractual dispute, the card was reissued with the name of his current team. In addition, one card was supposed to feature Browns Center Cody Risien but was withdrawn due to his retirement during training camp. The other card is card number 204, which shows Fred Marion of the New England Patriots.

 

2021 Joe Montana Panini Eminence .999 Fine Silver 1 Troy Ounce Bar Auto /8

2021 Joe Montana Panini Eminence .999 Fine Silver 1 Troy Ounce Bar Auto /8

Price: ($1575 PSA 10)

Year: 2021

Set number: –

Team: San Francisco 49ers

Many people believe that Joe Montana was the greatest quarterback that the NFL has ever seen. He led the 49ers to three Super Bowl victories over the course of his 16-year career and was awarded the Most Valuable Player of three separate Super Bowl games. Additionally, he established multiple records in the National Football League (NFL), including the record for the most passing yards in a single season with 5,123 yards in 1983. On the card, Montana can be shown triumphantly pumping his fist while standing on the field with a football in one hand and a number 16 jersey and helmet on his head. Since it was first introduced, this classic silver coin has maintained its level of popularity among silver collectors as well as sports lovers.

The lightweight silver rectangular medallion is included with the autographed card. It is housed in a box for further protection and has Golden Joe’s personal signature on the card itself, not the silver medallion. It is a fantastic collector’s item, and real football memorabilia fans will appreciate having it in their collections.

The Panini Eminence for the Year 2021, a PSA 10 price and its bidding indicates that the Joe Montana.999 Fine Silver 1 Troy Ounce Bar Auto /8 49ers is a highly prized and sought after card. This fact only serves to increase the card’s value.

 

2021 Joe Montana Topps Autograph Collector Card #72

  • Price: ($595.55 PSA 10)
  • Year: 1999
  • Set number:
  • Team: San Francisco 49ers

This Joe Montana PSA Topps Autograph collector card is an extremely rare item, limited to just 450 copies. The card has a gold sharpie signature and is hand-numbered. It also features the signature of the late player and is stamped with the Joe Montana Hologram.

The card measures 2 1/16 inches by 2 1/2 inches. In addition, it features a photo of the quarterback’s signature. While Montana didn’t have the strongest arms or the fastest feet, he led the San Francisco 49ers to countless victories during his career. His team destroyed their opponents, winning eight division titles and four Super Bowls. He was named MVP three times and broke countless passing records.

Joe Montana is widely considered to be the greatest quarterback in NFL history. This fact has resulted in an extremely high demand for his football cards. His rookie card, 1981 Topps Rookie Card #216 is considered to be the most valuable from his era. And it has been steadily increasing in value long after Montana’s last appearance in the NFL. Most collectors are looking for a mint or near-mint copy.

Joe Montana’s rookie card has a rare photo of him with his family and coach. His card was re-released during his 12th season after his Hall of Fame career. His card is a classic example of the “tall boy” era in football.

 

1990 Joe Montana NFL Pro Card 2 Ultimate Rare MINT

1990 Joe Montana NFL Pro Card 2 Ultimate Rare MINT

  • Price: ($190 PSA 10)
  • Year: 1990
  • Set number: 1990
  • Pro Set
  • Team: San Francisco 49ers

By 1990, Joe Montana had played enough football to warrant a spot on an NFL Pro card, as such cards typically only depict the player once they had competed at the top level of their sport. Joe is seen here on his 1990 card wearing the uniform of the San Francisco 49ers. Based on the card’s date, it is estimated that the photo was shot in 1989. In 1989, Montana was honored as both the NFL Offensive Player of the Year and the AP Athlete of the Year.

This card features Joe Montana while he was playing for the San Francisco 49ers. In the card, he is seen getting the upper hand. He has thrown for 1,795 yards, with 15 touchdowns and nine interceptions.

This card also has a game-used jersey on it. It was used by Montana in an NFL game, so owning a piece of his jersey is pretty cool. These cards were seeded in packs averaging one per hobby box. Also included are Steve Young and Jerry Rice.

This card is considered one of the most desirable football cards in history. This version of the popular Super Bowl quarterback was a 12-time Pro Bowler and 6-time All-Pro. The card also features a gold strip on the back, making it harder to find and more valuable.

Montana played for the San Francisco 49ers from 1979 to 1992.. He was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2000. He later became a Kansas City Chiefs player and led them to their first division title in 22 years.

Among Montana’s many cards, there is one in particular that is extremely collectible. The 1986 Topps Joe Montana card is PSA 10 worthy, and it sells for well over $300. 

 

1981 Joe Montana Topps Rookie Card #216

1981 topps football joe montana rookie rc 216

  • Avg. Recent Price: ($69,000 PSA 10)
  • Year: 1981
  • Card number: #216
  • Team: San Francisco 49ers

The 1981 Topps Joe Montana Card features a young Montana in his second season playing professional football. The #216 has an air-brushed front showing Montana ready to throw a football in his iconic number ’16’ Jersey in the gold and white 49ers uniform. The card has the classic green Tops border with Montana’s name and position in the bottom left corner. The background looks like a blurred stadium suggesting that Montana is participating in a serious football game.

Arguably the first major Joe Montana card, the #216 proved to be a phenomenal hit since the quarterback would go on to become one of the many NFL Hall of Famers. The card would mark the beginning of the 24-year-old Montana’s first season as the starting quarterback for the 49ers. Montana shocked the world with his strong performance and managed to finish the 1981 Regular season with a 13-3 record. He also saved the 49ers by making two 4th-quarter comebacks in Regular season games that were seemingly lost. 

Montana would go on to dominate the league with another rare feat. He led his team to Super Bowl XVI and became one of the few quarterbacks in NFL history to win a Super Bowl in their first year as the starter. Montana would also win the Super Bowl Most Valuable Player Award and establish the San Francisco 49ers dynasty throughout the 1980s.

Montana would orchestrate another iconic moment in 1982 by throwing a game-winning touchdown pass to receiver Dwight Clark to win the NFC Championship Game over the Dallas Cowboys. Clark’s fantastic chemistry with Montana led to a beautiful touchdown pass known as ‘the Catch.’ 

Joe Montana led the 49ers to four Super Bowl appearances (XVI, XIX, XXIII, XXIV) and was named MVP thrice. 

Therefore, #216 is one of the best Joe Montana Football card investments and has only two active PSA 10 versions in circulation. It is widely considered the most expensive Joe Montana football card as it shows the young quarterback before he would become one of the all-time greats. However, less authentic ungraded copies are available for as little as $86.

 

1984 Joe Montana Topps Glossy Send-In #13

1984 Topps Joe Montana Football Card

  • Avg. Recent Price: ($240.5 PSA 10)
  • Year: 1984
  • Card number: #13
  • Team: San Francisco 49ers

The 1984 Topps Joe Montana card series was another massive hit among fans due to Montana’s increasing popularity as a quarterback. The #13 card has a glossy cover featuring Montana in the ‘pocket’ ready to launch the football. 

Montana has his signature number ’16’ 49ers jersey with the red and gold variation. The black background has white lines drawn on it that seem to be the lines from a football playbook showing offense strategies and play routes, highlighting Montana’s razor-sharp mind and decisiveness on the field.

The bottom of the card features the player’s name and team on a yellow banner. The background shows a blurred full stadium giving a glimpse of Montana at the peak of his football prowess.

Montana continued to wreak havoc on his opponents. With his lead, the San Francisco 49ers became the first team in NFL history to win 15 games in the 1984 season. Montana went on to throw successful passes and got an invitation to his second consecutive pro bowl.  

In the 1984 SuperBowl, the 49ers faced the Miami Dolphins where Montana set an NFL record for most passing yards in a SuperBowl at 331. 

He also completed 24 of his 35 passes and became a 2-time Super Bowl MVP and 2-time Super Bowl champion. The 49ers’ head coach, Bill Walsh, declared Montana to be the greatest quarterback of all time.

Since it was another Super Bowl year for the San Francisco 49ers, the 1984 Topps #13 card is highly coveted by collectors today, with multiple copies available due to its unparalleled popularity, making it one of the best Joe Montana Football cards. Ungraded copies of the #13 cards cost under $4.

 

2000 Joe Montana Upper Deck Legends Legendary Jerseys

2000 Upper Deck Legends Joe Montana Football Card Legendary Jerseys

  • Avg. Recent Price: ($240.5 PSA 10)
  • Year: 2000
  • Set number: 2000 U.D. set
  • Team: San Francisco 49ers

The 2000 Upper Deck set sold like hotcakes due to the feeling of intimacy it grants buyers. The series got its name because the cards come with an authentic piece of the athlete’s game-worn jersey. The 2000 Upper Deck Joe Montana’s card has a red strip from his San Francisco 49ers jersey that he wore during a game. 

The card depicts a picture of Montana wearing his 49ers helmet looking off into the distance. The bottom has a square red strip of Montana’s jersey pasted on a white background. 

The quarterback’s name and jersey number are featured on the front of the card with ‘NFL Legends’ at the bottom. The reverse side of the card has lines written to describe the card’s quality and the rarity of the prize.

The 2000 Upper Deck Joe Montana card has become one of the most popular Joe Montana Football cards in circulation due to the grand legacy left behind by the legendary quarterback. 

Montana became known as the ‘comeback kid’ due to his eerie ability to rescue his team whenever they got close to defeat. He retired with a 92.3 passer rating and was a 2-time NFL MVP and 2-time Super Bowl MVP. 

Joe Montana also held many quarterback records for a long time and had a brief but successful run with the Kansas City Chiefs in the 1993 season. Therefore, this card is a great investment opportunity and is loved by fans worldwide. The same card is also available for around $130, but its authenticity is questionable.

 

1994 Joe Montana Finest Refractor #172

  • Price: ($3,216 PSA 10)
  • Year: 1994
  • Card number: #172
  • Team: Kansas City Chiefs

The 1994 #172 Joe Montana Football card is another popular contender in the list of the top football card investments. The card has a blue wash over it and features Montana in the Kansas City uniform with his number ’19’ jersey. Montana is clutching a football and seems to be scanning the field to find an open receiver to complete his pass. The card bears the legend’s name at the bottom with ‘Finest’ printed on the top. The card stays true to its name with a very fine print quality that makes for a sharp image with all details visible.

After Joe Montana’s 13-year run with the San Francisco 49ers ended, many feared that the quarterback was close to retirement, particularly due to some injury-plagued seasons. However, the champ was a sensational hit in Kansas City with a $10 million contract spanning over three years. 

Although Montana was injured for some of the 1993 seasons, he continued to blaze through football games. He led the Chiefs to a divisional round win, a first for the franchise in 22 years, and continued to prove himself as an expert defense reader with a spectacular victory against the Pittsburgh Steelers in overtime.

Montana would suffer a concussion later in the season but made another Pro Bowl appearance and enabled the Kansas City Chiefs to make it to the playoffs in 1994, before announcing his retirement in 1995.  

The #172 card is very popular because of the ‘comeback kid’s successful return at a time when speculations regarding his retirement were spreading. Montana continued to dominate and certainly improved the Chiefs’ ranking. 

Fans have flocked to purchase this card and consider it one of the best Joe Montana football cards. Although the original PSA 10 variants of the 1994 #172 cards are quite expensive, ungraded versions are available for $137.

 

1983 Joe Montana Topps #169

  • Avg. Recent Price: ($855 PSA 10)
  • Year: 1983
  • Card number: #169
  • Team: San Francisco 49ers

One of the best Joe Montana football cards, the 1983 Topps #169 card features a 25-year-old Montana in his second season as the starting quarterback after his phenomenal Super Bowl win the previous year. The card has a determined Montana donning his iconic red and gold 49ers uniform looking straight at the viewer. 

His face mask is off and the champ seems to be in a practice session. The card has a vintage feel with a green and white border, featuring the typical Topps-style athlete’s name and position on the bottom.

Montana famously cemented his nickname as the “Comeback kid” and “Comeback Joe” in college. The quarterback led his team, the University of Notre Dame Fighting Irish, to victory twice to win the Cotton Bowl. 

He would eerily prove to be a ‘good luck charm’ for all the teams he would play for. Although Montana was not the starting quarterback on his college team, he would stun everyone by throwing for 4,121 yards, with 268 completions on 515 attempts and 25 touchdowns. 

The San Francisco 49ers would draft the 23-year-old athlete in the third round of the 1979 NFL Draft. Montana would face the same challenges as his college years, playing the backup quarterback for his first two seasons, but soon the champ got his shot. 

He became the 49ers’ starting quarterback when he led them to the 1981 Super Bowl XVI victory over the Cincinnati Bengals. Joe was named the Super Bowl MVP after throwing for 157 yards and became a one-time Super Bowl champion in his first year as the starter.  

He was a six-time NFL All-Pro First Team selection and played in eight NFL Pros Bowls. Montana led the NFL in per-game passing attempts and yards, five times in pass completion percentage, and twice in touchdown passes. 

Montana became the undisputed all-time best in his 1989 season when he threw for 3,521 yards and a shocking 26 touchdowns. He ended the season with a league-leading 70.2% completion percentage as San Francisco went on to acquire 11 wins in regular season games. The 49ers would go on to annihilate the Denver Broncos 55-10 in Super Bowl XXIV. 

Joe Montana was named the 1989 Offensive Player of the Year, the 1989 PFWA, the 1989 Bert Bell Award winner, and won the NEA NFL MVP and the AP NFL Most Valuable Player for his first of two consecutive seasons. Montana’s trademark calmness, ability to design game-winning plays and strategies, and precise throwing made him one of the best quarterbacks to play football. He retired with the Kansas City Chiefs after scoring 40,551 passing yards and 273 touchdowns on 3,409 completions in 5,391 attempts. Joe Montana was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2000 and is an active non-playing figure in the NFL today.

 

Final thoughts

Joe Montana Football trading cards are available globally to celebrate the achievements of a true football legend. Each card captures the champion in moments that have become immortal and which fans are willing to shell out big bucks for. 

Investing in football cards is a fun hobby and prices keep going higher or lower depending on the card, its authenticity, and its population. The face of the athlete undoubtedly helps, and none more so than the ‘Comeback Kid’ Joe Montana.

Leave a Comment